Sameera Casmod | sameerac@radioislam.co.za
20 January 2025 | 14:10 CAT
2-minute read

Image: News24

The ongoing rescue efforts at the Stilfontein Shaft 11 mine continue to grip the nation as emergency teams battle to bring miners, both alive and deceased, to the surface. The tragedy has reignited contentious debates surrounding illegal mining, government responsibility, and humanitarian ethics.

As bodies are recovered and survivors emerge, discussions intensify over who bears responsibility for the catastrophe. ActionSA President Herman Mashaba and Zaki Mamdoo, spokesperson for the Workers’ and Socialist Party, weighed in on the crisis during an interview on Radio Islam International, presenting starkly different perspectives.

Mr Mashaba condemned the breakdown of law enforcement and blamed the government for failing to secure the nation’s borders and uphold the rule of law. He criticised illegal mining as a symptom of systemic failure, arguing that those who entered the mine voluntarily must accept the risks. “South Africa is not a playground of criminality,” he stated firmly, placing the onus on the government for allowing porous borders and a weakened justice system.

In contrast, Mr Mamdoo delivered a scathing critique of Operation Vala Umgodi, describing it as a brutal campaign of “starvation, torture, and murder.” He likened the events at Stilfontein to the Marikana massacre and accused authorities of inhumanely starving miners trapped underground. “No one chooses starvation over arrest,” Mamdoo argued, emphasising the desperate conditions of those working in illegal mines. He also highlighted the broader socio-economic context, pointing to corporate negligence and inadequate mine rehabilitation as root causes driving vulnerable individuals into hazardous artisanal mining.

The rhetoric intensified when Mashaba dismissed concerns about the miners’ welfare, calling them victims of exploitation by criminal syndicates linked to major corporations. He reiterated that supporting illegal activities undermines national security. Meanwhile, Mamdoo demanded accountability from mining giants, urging reparations and the nationalisation of the industry to empower workers and communities through cooperative ownership models.

The rescue mission at Shaft 11 continues under harrowing conditions, with calls growing for a comprehensive inquiry into mine closures, corporate social responsibility, and the rights of workers. The unfolding tragedy has become a flashpoint for reflecting on the country’s governance, economic inequalities, and humanity in the face of desperation.

As South Africans watch the events in Stilfontein, the question remains: how do we balance compassion with law enforcement in a nation grappling with poverty and systemic failure?

Listen to the full interview on Sabaahul Muslim with Moulana Sulaimaan Ravat.