CURRENTLY ON AIR ⇒
  • The Early Breakfast
    Tuesday, 5:00 am - 6:00 am
    [ - ]

feedback@radioislam.org.za

logo


((( Listen Live )))))
Radio Islam Logo


Why the Question Itself is Incorrect?

Our Limitations in Comprehending the Divine
Passing a verdict on something requires first comprehending it. Since human beings are finite creatures, they are incapable of fully comprehending the reality of an eternal Allah and grasping His Perfection. After all, they do not have direct access to Allah, nor the visual or mental capacity to handle such access were it granted, nor do they have access to anything comparable that would allow their imaginations to construct a mental image. Hence, the necessary antecedent for critiquing Allah, which is comprehending Allah, does not exist. The Most High said:
لَيْسَ كَمِثْلِهِۦ شَىْءٌ ۖ وَهُوَ ٱلسَّمِيعُ ٱلْبَصِيرُ
There is nothing like Him, for He ˹alone˺ is the All-Hearing, All-Seeing. [ash-Shura 42: 11].

For this reason, we say that it is beyond the human mind to describe Allah on its own, independently, without revelation. Humans can and should think deeply about the signs of Allah, inferring from them some undeniable truths about the Creator and His attributes. However, this must be done with an awareness that veils have been lowered between their minds and the full essence of Allah’s nature. Intelligence here involves realizing the limits of one’s intelligence.

For instance, examining the magnitude and magnificent design of our universe allows us to infer the Greatness and Graciousness of the One Who brought it into existence. However, our minds are limited in what they can decipher from these signs, and we must therefore refrain from trying to completely comprehend what is locked behind an impregnable door.
These human limitations are also why the Qur’an kept the discussion on Allah—though quite elaborate—limited to certain divine traits, due to the mind’s limited ability to grasp the Divine. Given these limitations, it is inappropriate for a human being to casually question Allah’s Wisdom in asking to be worshipped.

Presuming the Humanness of Allah is a Flawed Premise
Where does this question regarding the Creator’s “need” for worship come from? Why does the issue of how worship “benefits” Him represent a central theme of those asking this question? These questions stem from the human tendency for anthropomorphism (likening non-humans to humans). One major problem with anthropomorphism is the assumption that Allah is comparable to the human being in every respect, with no dissimilarity whatsoever. Such an overextended analogy may unfold in the following fashion: people’s actions and requests are generated by need, therefore all actions and requests result from need, including the actions and requests of Allah.

Thus, those who think that Allah asks for worship in order to fulfil a need or to compensate for some deficiency are essentially anthropomorphizing the Divine. Such people imagine that all requests are generated by the desire to fill a void because their lifetime of experience with humans suggests that this is why people request things. However, extending that motive to Allah when we do not fully comprehend His Nature is clearly fallacious, especially when what we do understand of His Nature—through reason and revelation—indicates that He does not have any needs.

Not Every Request is Prompted by the Requester’s Need
Even among humans, not all requests communicate need. Consider a physician who asks a patient to open his mouth in order to administer medicine. This physician would love for the patient to obey this request, not for personal benefit, but because obeying will result in benefit for the patient. Similarly, Allah’s love for worship points to the benefits that worship entails for humans. Consider a wealthy person who asks a beggar to extend his hand and loves that he complies so that he may hand him money. These examples are better analogies for God’s desire to be worshipped; His loving to be worshipped and obeyed does not necessitate His need for it, nor is any request—even among people—always associated with a desire for more of something.

These and many other examples demonstrate that merely requesting something does not indicate a need for that thing; requests are used for a variety of communicative intentions, many of which do not involve any need on the part of the requester. As for Allah, the most perfect essence and traits belong to Him. He is not increased by people’s worship in the least; rather, opportunities to worship and do good are ultimately offerings from Allah to humans—considering He gifted them the ability to do good in the first place.

ADVERTISE HERE

Prime Spot!!!

Contact:
advertisingadmin@radioislam.co.za 

Related Articles

Bilaadush Shaam

Bilaadush Shaam

Shaam in the Words of the Prophet ﷺ When the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ spoke about places, his words were precise, intentional, and full of divine wisdom. Among the regions repeatedly mentioned in his sayings is Shaam — an ancient and blessed land comprising modern-day...

read more
Spiritual Reflections from the Hijri Calendar

Spiritual Reflections from the Hijri Calendar

The Hijri calendar is not merely a timeline of months and days — it is a map for spiritual growth. Each month of the Islamic year offers a unique opportunity to reconnect with Allah, reflect on one’s soul, and realign with a life of purpose. The beauty of the Hijri...

read more
The Sacred Months

The Sacred Months

In Islam, time is not just a neutral passage of moments — it carries weight, meaning, and divine wisdom. Among the twelve months of the Islamic calendar, four are known as the Sacred Months (Al-Ashhur Al-Hurum). These months were honoured even before Islam and have...

read more
The Structure of the Hijri Calendar

The Structure of the Hijri Calendar

The Hijri or Islamic calendar is a lunar calendar composed of 12 months based on the cycles of the moon. Unlike the Gregorian calendar, which is solar and aligns with the earth’s journey around the sun, the Islamic calendar follows the phases of the moon — from one...

read more
The Islamic Calendar

The Islamic Calendar

The Origins of the Islamic Calendar The Islamic, or Hijri, calendar is more than a way to track time — it is a spiritual compass that guides Muslims through the rhythms of worship, remembrance, and reflection. Unlike the Gregorian calendar, which is solar-based, the...

read more
Right to Return

Right to Return

The right to return is more than a political demand for millions of Palestinians — it is a deeply personal and collective struggle for justice, identity, and dignity. Seventy-five years since the Nakba of 1948, when over 700,000 Palestinians were forcibly displaced,...

read more

Subscribe to our Newsletter

0 Comments