Neelam Rahim | neelam@radioislam.co.za

3-minute read
28 November 2024 | 16:50 CAT

File photo: Bullets, a gun and police tape pictured. Image Credits: SABC_News_-Crime-scene-1

South Africa’s persistently high murder rate underscores the urgent need for strategic interventions to address gun violence. Gun Free South Africa’s Adele Kirsten, in an interview with Radio Islam International, emphasized that firearms remain the leading cause of murder, accounting for nearly 45% of all cases. This staggering figure highlights a deep-seated challenge tied to the country’s socio-economic fabric and its historical relationship with guns.

Kirsten highlighted the global evidence, citing over 130 studies, which consistently show that countries with stringent gun laws and lower gun ownership experience significantly fewer firearm-related deaths. “Reducing gun availability directly reduces gun deaths,” she stated. Despite this, South Africa maintains provisions allowing firearm ownership for self-defence, a category absent in more than 60% of countries with national gun laws.

Addressing the issue of firearms for self-protection, Kirsten noted, “There’s no evidence globally that guns are effective for self-defense. While there are anecdotes of successful defense, policy must be guided by big data, not isolated cases.” She warned that having a firearm in the home introduces risks such as theft and misuse, often outweighing perceived safety benefits.

Drawing comparisons, Kirsten cautioned against likening South Africa to nations like Finland or New Zealand, where high gun ownership coincides with low gun-related crime. Instead, she advocated examining countries with similar socio-economic contexts, such as Brazil or Jamaica, which also grapple with significant gun violence.

Historical and cultural factors compound the issue in South Africa, where firearms have long been embedded in its colonial and apartheid history. Moreover, high unemployment and inequality drive violence, though Kirsten stressed that poverty alone does not equate to crime.

As debates around gun control persist globally, Kirsten reiterated that strong laws, rigorous checks, and reduced firearm accessibility are essential to curbing violence. She directed listeners to Gun Free South Africa’s website for detailed research and policy briefs, emphasizing the importance of evidence-based advocacy in shaping effective legislation.

“Gun violence isn’t inevitable,” Kirsten concluded, “but addressing it requires a concerted effort grounded in data and a commitment to prioritizing human safety over weapon ownership.”

Listen to the full interview on The Daily Round Up with Moulana Junaid Kharsahy and Adele Kirsten here.