Neelam Rahim | neelam@radioislam.co.za
3-minute read
17 July 2025 | 19:00 CAT

📸 Minister in the Presidency Khumbudzo Ntshavheni at the recent national security briefing, where “coup talks” raised concern across the country. Photo credit: News24

Recent remarks by Minister in the Presidency, Khumbudzo Ntshavheni, have stirred widespread concern after she flagged a potential coup threat among South Africa’s key national security risks in her 2024–2028 strategy briefing. The mention has drawn criticism, confusion, and renewed scrutiny over the country’s fragile political landscape.

Security analyst Jackie Cilliers, speaking to Radio Islam International, dismissed fears of a classic military takeover, clarifying: “The version of the national security strategy that was released does not refer to a coup as a threat.” He added that the Minister’s wording likely pointed to political instability linked to factions such as the MK Party and the EFF, rather than an imminent military seizure of power. “I would almost say gaffe,” Cilliers noted. “A bad choice of words that created a lot of unnecessary worry.”

The strategy document, although comprehensive, has been overshadowed by what many see as a misstep. Critics argue the implications damage investor confidence and distract from more systemic issues: “We have enough problems,” Cilliers said, referencing past embarrassments including farm murder rhetoric and controversial international diplomacy.

The broader concern remains persistent unrest driven by high unemployment, inequality, and failed service delivery. “The same symptoms remain,” Cilliers warned, pointing to the 2021 unrest in KwaZulu-Natal. He referenced the Sandy Africa Report and the Zondo Commission’s findings on dysfunction within the presidency and security cluster: “We don’t know to what extent those recommendations have been taken on board,” he said.

Despite steps to overhaul the State Security Agency and disentangle domestic from foreign intelligence, questions linger about real reform. “We don’t know what they do, because everything is a secret,” Cilliers remarked, adding that cadre deployment continues to weaken trust in the system.

Yet, there are glimmers of progress. The judiciary’s independence has been strengthened, and the turnaround at SARS is cited as a model. “All of this is achievable with the right leadership,” Cilliers stressed. “It’s not more commissions we need, but competent people in the right positions.”

As South Africa enters a new phase under a Government of National Unity, the need to restore public trust and bolster security institutions has never been more urgent.

Listen to the full interview on the Daily Round-Up with Moulana Nunaid Kharsany and Jackie Cillier.